London Mayor Sadiq Khan has become the latest political leader to take a look at hotels and wonder whether there was a golden egg about to be laid and should he get a cut of the yolk.
When asked about a bed tax – something he has been in favour of for some time – Khan told the Centre for London annual conference: “I’m happy to look into where it’s worked, what the issues are in relation to that particular policy… we’ll be looking at what cities are doing not just across Europe, but in the UK as well.”
There are of course reasons to have bed taxes and they are: you want to limit tourism numbers because your island is sinking and if you make some money as well then that’s not too bad (your island is, after all, sinking), and you want to make money (and some of this might be used to offset the cost of having tourists wearing away at the pavement flagstones).
What happens to the money is a whole other thing. Only last week David Chapman, executive director, UKHospitality Cymru, was commenting on similar plans in Wales when he said: “While we don’t agree with the introduction of visitor levies, which place an additional burden on already over-stretched businesses and impact the ability of Welsh tourism to remain competitive… it’s crucial that hospitality is made central to the process.
“The sector must be the primary beneficiary of any funds directly raised, so that we can invest in the local economy, drive job creation, and boost economic growth right across Wales.”
But the innocent voter/taxpayer has no say in how money is spent. They do have a say, if not large, in whether the tax is raised in the first place.
The sector is, of course, largely opposed to anything which increases the room rate but doesn’t go to them, which at least indicates a firm grasp of capitalism, so we’re all pleased about that. Arguments are that anything which raises rate is offputting to visitors.
Looking at London, there has been no suggestion that over tourism is afflicting the capital, with the locals capable of avoiding hot spots without malice on account of no one really fancying spending too long on Oxford Street.
The capital does, however, need cash. The Institute for Fiscal Studies estimated that a charge of £1 per person per night would raise approximately £420m per year in England. The Northern Powerhouse Partnership estimated that £428m could be raised. By comparison, council tax raises about £30bn and business rates about £25bn per year in England.
The tide does seem to be in favour of such taxes, but what do they actually do?
According to a study by Rhys ap Gwilym, Senior Lecturer in Economics and Linda Osti, Senior Lecturer in Tourism Management, University of Bangor found that the impact on tourism levels was inconclusive.
The pair said: “As part of an ongoing research project, we looked at seven different destinations in which tourist taxes are levied to look at how the money raised is then spent.
“For most places, tourism tax revenues were being used to fund marketing and branding – so invested directly into promoting more tourism. The income was also commonly used to fund tourism infrastructure, from public toilets and walking or cycling paths to a multi-billion dollar convention centre in Orange County, Florida.
“In general, tourism taxes have been implemented successfully across the destinations we looked at, and there is little evidence of tourists being put off from visiting.”
So they might not deter visitors, they might actually bring more in. But do they put them off staying in hotels? At Bangor, the two said: “For many tourism destinations, the major problem is not overnight tourists, but rather day visitors who use local resources while making little in the way of a financial contribution. For these reasons, taxes might also be used to deter day visits and instead encourage longer stays.”
And as for the impact on hotels themselves, as one study undertaken for the European Commission by PwC back in 2017 pointed out, there have been a lot of column inches on the subject, but not a lot of academic research. VAT is of much greater interest than a fiver a night on rooms and whether it can be passed through to the consumer.
The report instead commented that hotels should consider how the tax raised might be spent on making a destination more attractive, more competitive. London would benefit from more bins and public toilets. As one New York policeman once told us: “London’s a very dirty city, ma’am” and we don’t go into how that came up.
It is hard to get worked up into the usual emotional free fall that the sector likes to get into whenever tax gets mentioned, but there is a note of caution to be had here, as raised by David Chapman in Wales. If all things were equal, a bed tax might indeed go to make for a lovelier London. But given the state of public finance, it’s likely the money will go to keep London scraping along. And that does not make for a more competitive destination at all.