As we peer through the mists of days off and voluminous eating habits into the new year, many in the sector are once again forecasting a year of throbbing M&A. It’s what we all want, if only for the funny names it produces. AccMar. HyAcc. Marton. OK, the less one isn’t so hilarious.
But are we going to get it?
In the US, the return of Donald Trump has created an unseemly bubbling over of emotions on the part of the capitalist community, with a focus on lawyers. The Don, you see, has a different view of competition than those pesky Democrats.
EY chief economist Gregory Daco told the Independent: “President Trump’s administration is set to continue its push for deregulation across various sectors and existing governmental agencies, aiming to lighten the regulatory load on both the economy and businesses.”
Those heavy regulatory loads are so peevish, of course. There is also the hope that interest rates will continue their downwards trajectory, something which may be driven off course if Trump also indulges in his love of tariffs. Until these are confirmed the mood on Wall Street is much more about bonhomie and bonuses than being forced to buy a Tesla because all other electric cars cost 15 times as much.
But will this have an impact on the hotel sector? The FTC has only shown an interest in the hotel sector twice this year: over the Choice/Wyndham kerfuffle (ChoiceHam!) and the tidying up after the Marriott/Starwood imported data breach.
In the case of the latter, Marriott agreed to pay $52m, promise to improve security and provide its US customers with a way to request deletion of personal information associated with their email address or loyalty rewards account number.
The group said: “Protecting guests’ personal data remains a top priority for Marriott. These resolutions reaffirm the company’s continued focus on and significant investments in maintaining and adapting its programs and systems to assess, identify, and manage risks from evolving cybersecurity threats.
“As indicated in the agreements with the FTC and the state Attorneys General, Marriott makes no admission of liability with respect to the underlying allegations.”
It’s been a long journey, but an excellent ‘buyer beware’ cautionary tale.
At the sadly-not-to-be ChoiceHam, there was much scuffling between the two over how a deal would affect consumer and franchisee choice.
Wyndham objected to claims that a merger would be anti competitive, saying: “Wyndham arbitrarily segments hotels based on STR chain scales, but STR chain scales are not meaningful under antitrust law. Wyndham overlooks that Choice and Wyndham account for only 10% of U.S. room revenue” and that other hotel brand stables were also available.
After the dust had settled, FTC Bureau of Competition director Henry Liu said: “The FTC will continue to monitor this industry. We will not hesitate to enforce the antitrust laws to ensure that travellers have access to quality, affordable lodging and that hotel franchisors compete on the merits for franchisees.”
But what’s he looking for? The point made by Wyndham is one which has been made during other deals: the big hotel brands may feel like they own the world, but they actually own a small part of the market.
Does this mean that they’re ripe for a merger? If only. But the market has changed since Marriott/Starwood. The brands are still eager to add more brands, but the days of paying spirited prices are waning; instead we are seeing low-cost, low-risk licensing deals such as Marriott/Sonder. The big stables have a tonne of brands now, it’s all about filling spaces with an eye to what’s missing from loyalty programmes instead. We had been looking forward to Accor selling off budget or luxury, but Baz turned against it.
With the hotel brands now asset light, we are seeing greater interest in the property, particularly in the Reits, who have been buying and merging and thinking about merging all year. Interest is in the bricks and mortar, less so the brand over it.
So will we see more deals next year? Yes. Will they involve funny names? Probably not. But lawyers still have reasons to be cheerful heading into a new year, so that’s something.