Why don’t you understand me?

It is still very much Out and About January here at NewDog PR and this week we very much enjoyed attending EY’s annual hospitality event and not just because of the array of different flavours of Fanta which were on offer. Two more than we had even been aware of*.

This annual Where Are We Now state of the nation event kicked off with an economist, as these things do, for no other reason than they tend to have a strong grasp on economics. 

Peter Arnold, EY’s chief economist, started with “hospitality and leisure is one of those weathervane sectors for the wider economy”, which is a lot of responsibility for a sector where the focus is on leaving all your cares behind.

The message was mixed. He said: “One of the strategic errors this government made was the NI increase, which was counter to the message of growth. They had ruled out taxes on working people so had ruled out a number of levers to try and raise serious revenue. 

“The lack of political and business experience in government didn’t recognise that an increase in NI on employers created a perfect storm, particularly for those hiring on minimum wage. Funding from NI is anti-growth.

“We expect to see strong wage growth continue this year, which should support a return in confidence and spending. But for this year we expect to see a difficult story for GDP growth given the tightening in financial markets and limited momentum coming out of 2024.”

He confirmed that the UK was in a stagflationary environment at the moment and said that growth this year would be 1.1% to 1.3% – or, as he put it, “tepid”.

Marching into this tepid environment is Donald Trump, who would run hot in Boris Johnson’s walk-in fridge. 

“It’s a story of US strength at the moment,” said Arnold. “Donald Trump is a bit like AI: everyone is talking about him, everyone thinks he’s going to change the world. But it’s going to be a mixed picture. His tax cuts are likely to be a boost, but immigration policies are likely to be inflationary 

“Globally, tariffs are likely to take big chunks out of Mexico and Canada, but also the US. The consensus is largely that he’ll use as a negotiation tool.”

And talking of negotiation tools, there was discussion around the financing environment, with Desmond Taljaard, deputy chair, L&R Properties, commenting: “In the words of Fred Pontin: ‘book early’. If you want debt, be clear about your business plan and be prepared to waste a lot of time”.

Taljaard was confident that education, education was the route to success in the sector, pointing that  “a lot of the people lending long term in hospitality understand the opportunity”, despite the ups and downs the sector follows as it pursues its role of weathervane.

And this takes us to one of the core issues of our sector. Everybody knows it, nobody knows it. The public knows hotels, it knows how they work. But very few people, be that lenders or, say, political figures, really know how they work.

Allen Simpson, deputy chief executive, UK Hospitality, came with the cheery message of “this year is going to get much much tougher” only to be challenged about the organisation’s role in interceding with the government. He acknowledged, when pressed, that we weren’t going to get the VAT cut which has been the focus of campaigning since before UKHospitality existed anytime soon, but said that it would be important to lay the groundwork.

In the meantime, what for hotels? Our need is for quality team members across the piece. Keir Starmer’s need is for something to draw the Red Wall close and see off Nigel Farage at the next election. How about a friendly sector riddled with entry-level jobs which keep people within their community and offer career paths?

And not just entry-level jobs, but jobs up to CEO. For too long we have allowed ourselves to be lumped in with ‘hair or care’, which is not doing anything for our reputation. Hospitality is not a last-resort job. 

Felicity Black-Roberts, SVP development, EMEA, Hyatt, said: “The immediate post-pandemic hiring crisis is gone, but there are specific pockets where there are issues. Do people view the industry as somewhere they can have a career? We talk about it all the time but the message doesn’t seem to be getting through.”

Getting that message out of our echo chamber is critical to us being seen as more than just a venue where other industries hang out. 

Simpson did not “want to have a risk argument” with government. It’s hard to see how we as a sector are viewed as anything but risk when we are always out with our VAT begging bowl. Surely there is less risk in offering a win-win? Who wouldn’t want to see Starmer onstage next to a hospitality leader, extolling our virtues, changing our image? 

The US has a hotelier as a president. Much as we don’t want to be the 52nd state after Canada, there is still something there to aspire to. We just need to tell our story.

 

 

*Lemon and lime 

Scroll to Top