Data set for sector upheaval 

The hotel sector is damned if it does and damned if it doesn’t. Bring in standards, they said. Let the sign above the door reassure us, they said. Let us sleep easy about the buffet offering, they said. Oh we don’t want everything to be the same, they now say. Cookie cutter bad. Same old buffet bad. 

There is no pleasing some people. Which brings us to this week’s news that the Competition and Markets Authority has launched an investigation into suspected sharing of competitively-sensitive information among Hilton, IHG Hotels and Marriott using STR, owned by CoStar.

The CMA said that, at this stage, no assumptions should be made about whether the law has been broken, it’s just taking a look. Following a period of investigation and information gathering, the CMA may issue a statement of objections if it comes to the provisional view that competition law has been infringed.

So on the one hand; hotels need more data to be a more grown-up asset class. On the other hand; don’t share the data too much. Tsk. 

Regular viewers of the hotel sector will recall this isn’t the first time around the mulberry bush for IHG and the CMA. In 2012 the CMA investigated IHG, Expedia and booking.com about pricing agreements. The upshot was a lot of having to learn and explain what rate parity was and why it wasn’t necessarily to the benefit of all.

This time around, the CMA is making “naughty, naughty” noises about “rival businesses” who might  “share competitively-sensitive information”. IHG had no comment to make, Marriott’s latest press release was about new routes for the Ritz Carlton yacht. Hilton was highlighting cherry blossom season in Washington DC and CoStar had some thoughts on AI in the housing market. As a PR agency, these all seem like solid strategies when lacking any actual accusation of law breaking.

 The most fascinating aspect of the case so far – in an echo of the 2012 investigation – is that the CMA would have the first clue about what is going on in the hotel sector. Certainly, the UK government’s activities of the past few months suggest that it doesn’t, but maybe it does after all. Maybe the CMA only got involved because hotels complained that their trading levels couldn’t support the increase in Business Rates and they thought that couldn’t possibly be the case and took a look at the data. 

Data sharing or not is, admittedly, an easier idea to parse than rate parity, so the CMA has a fighting chance of working out which way is up and we look forward to this acting as a educator for government. And, as a side note, that there is a ‘cartel hotline’ at the CMA makes it sound like a pretty fun place to work and maybe somewhere with a gin still in the basement. 

One sector observer speculated to us that an OTA could have made the call to the cartel line. If hotels are able to access forward-booking data, not just historic figures, this puts them on a level-playing field with the OTAs, which wouldn’t be the point at all.

Are they sharing data, are they not? This is a small sector and a fair amount of data does get shared about the place anyway, although we should point out that cartels are bad and also illegal. If all the groups were involved in, say, rate setting, that would be the majority of the branded market and that’s very much not fair to everyone else. And, again, illegal. 

So come back in around six months to see what happens next. 

What happened last time the CMA got into the hotel sector? Yes, we all sort of learned about rate parity, but the upshot after three years of pained explanations was that hotel groups were then allowed to offer discounted rates to closed groups; such as members of their loyalty programmes. 

A decade later and, for some hotel companies, their loyalty programme is all they are. Will the CMA force a similar hand break turn in the future of the sector? Rate setting by Magic Eight Ball? Royal decree? Something to do with crypto? We look forward to the impact of external forces. 

Scroll to Top