Marriott owners rebel agains the ecosystem

There are distinct signs of déja vu all over again this month, with a British prime minister resigning, a heatwave that took many and their clothing choices somehow by surprise and hotel owners being grumpy about loyalty programmes. 

In the case of the latter, The Wall Street Journal has run a story around a letter from a group of owners in the US who feel they should be getting a cut of the cash Marriott raises from its credit card. 

We’ve looked at this before, most recently last November, when we noted that Marriott was no longer a hotel company, but a credit card company. On the group’s Q3 earnings call, there was much chat around the intermeshed credit card and loyalty card setup the group has been benefitting from. 

CFO Leeny Oberg told analysts: “It’s really worth remembering that the co-brand card payments actually account for more than half of the Marriott Bonvoy programme funding. In 2024, our credit card branding fees were $660,000,000 And we’re looking at that growing this year 9% in 2025 from, again, the continued powerful combination of the credit card partners and Marriott Bonvoy.”

CEO and president Tony Capuano added: “As Bonvoy continues to grow, that growth translates to more cardholders, more spend, and we expect to see that reflected in growing co-brand credit card fees”.

Tasty, tasty fees. For Marriott. What was itching at the throat of the owners pen palling with the WSJ was that the points earned on these cards and with partners such as Starbucks are redeemed at their hotels. For not brilliant recompense.

The not brilliant part has always been the case, of course, but the owners felt things were getting away from them rather and the letter made its point succinctly: “Hotel owners are absorbing an increasing share of the programme’s costs while Marriott captures an increasing share of its revenue”. 

Now, the point of a loyalty programme is loyalty (in case you thought it was earning fees) so you could make a case that guests like Bonvoy because of the wider points earning potential and therefore that’s great because they will stay in more Marriott hotels, as per the promise. And because no loyalty programme is so brilliant for guests that they stay by redeeming points every time, they must pay at some point. 

But it seems that pay off is tilting in the US, with the owners making ominous threatening noises about how much nicer Expedia was.

Marriott responded by saying that it was taking hotels’ concerns seriously and that it was improving the compensation on high-demand nights, but owners are likely to remain fractious as the fees from the credit card near $1bn. 

Marriott’s business plan in recent years has been Bonvoy and creating the largest scheme and biggest portfolio has made a convincing case for owners who are looking for that sort of thing. But this latest gripe has come just as AI is changing that most hideous of sector terms; the travel funnel.

According to Wyndham almost 40% of travel searches are coming through LLMs, something which prompted the group to launch Wyndham apps on both Claude and ChatGPT. Currently, the traveller has to go looking for these apps to use them, which isn’t ideal, but that will all change in the next evolution of the LLMs. 

In May, when Wyndham was talking about its AI hopes, Marriott wasn’t following suit – although it is also working with Google –  but last week saw it announce its AI distribution plan, with Bonvoy dead centre. The beta launch of Ask Bonvoy, a new conversational, natural language search experience, will be available on the brand website and Marriott Bonvoy apps. Assuming all goes well and it doesn’t direct guests into the nearest pig farm with no turning circle, rollout is due later this year. 

“Travellers are increasingly looking for faster, more intuitive ways to search, explore, and plan their trips,” said Drew Pinto, EVP and chief revenue & technology officer, Marriott International. “Grounded in Marriott’s own data and backed by the power of Marriott Bonvoy’s portfolio of offerings, Ask Bonvoy is designed to meet travellers in a modern way at every point in their journey, whether they know exactly where and when they’d like to travel or are just beginning their trip discovery. Our measured launch allows us to learn directly from our customers on how they like to search so we can refine and adapt before we scale globally.”

Ignoring if possible the temptation to add ‘like the young people like’ after ‘in a modern way’, this strategy relies on the endless belief that hotel companies have: that guests come to them to search first. This isn’t true, although there is potential here to keep the guest close once they’ve landed by providing a full-service information drenching. And then a nice discount for members. 

Encouraging travellers to visit the app will require them to be incentivised to do so. Will this be through the massive number of points they accrued paying for their Uber on the Marriott credit card? It’s unlikely that Marriott is going to start sharing its revenue with hotels and for anyone who doesn’t get that, Harvard has an MBA that will clear that right up. 

What Marriott will have to get better at is that communication with owners. Maybe AI can help. Distribution has led hotels to be commoditised, but owners don’t like to feel that way and Marriott isn’t quite at the Amazon scale where it can afford to irritate a certain percentage of the ecosystem, knowing they’ll be back. In an era where guests are looking to value – as Marriott has proved with its mid-market moves – owners to need to feel the same. 

Scroll to Top