Airbnb’s blame, shame, lame game 

For those of you who learned your morality at the feet of your grandmother, you’ll be aware of the dangers of the blame game. The relevant grandmother in this case would never have referred to it as a ‘game’ of course and half an hour standing in the corner of the kitchen facing the wall to you.

In the non-AI search for suitable quotes to illustrate this (grandmothers take a dim view of AI) Forbes delivered unto us “when a man points his finger at someone else, he should remember three of his fingers are pointing at himself”. Go on try it, it’s true. This quote – by everyone’s favourite, ‘anonymous’ – has that great bumper sticker quality that causes you to nod your head sagely, so we’ll stick with it.

And that takes us directly to Airbnb, where this week it’s fingers akimbo after summer dawned with a fresh attack on tourists in Spain with water pistols. Overtourism, the group told the Financial Times, was not its fault, it was the fault of (and you’ll enjoy this) hotels. 

Airbnb backed this up with a report on the matter, with Theo Yedinsky, Airbnb’s VP Public Policy, commenting: “If cities are serious about easing overtourism, they must address the overwhelming impact of hotels. Europe needs more homes – not hotels – yet cities are building more hotels as the construction of housing in the region nears a decade low.”

In the name of public health it seems wise to warn you that, if you work in hotels – and we think you do – you might want to stop reading now, lest you start bleeding from the eyes laughing. It’s not a look and it’s hard to get the stains out of your impeccable white shirt. 

Anyway. Airbnb went on: “Hotels …accounted for almost 80% of guest nights across the bloc in 2023 and 2024. It also shows that between 2021 and 2023, guest nights in the EU’s 10 most-visited cities increased by over 200 million – or 2.5x – with hotels accounting for 75% of this growth”. 

It went on and on. “Central Amsterdam has 15x more hotel rooms or similar accommodations than Airbnb listings. There are approximately seven hotel beds for each short-term rental bed in Barcelona’s Old Town. In the post-covid recovery period from 2021-2024, hotels accounted for 93% of the increase in guest nights in Amsterdam and 76% in Barcelona.  With fewer accommodation options, hotel occupancy and prices have soared, with prices rising by 50% in Amsterdam and 35% in Barcelona between 2019 and spring 2025.”

This would be the point where the eye bleeding becomes an issue and goggles may be required. Regular viewers and members of the sector will recall that there are restrictions on hotel development in both Barcelona and Amsterdam. So, er, that’s what Airbnb wants? Right? Those of us with GCSE economics will also note that if you restrict the number of hotel rooms, but visitor numbers stay the same or increase, then, er, of course prices will rise. So Airbnb wants more rooms to lower the prices? No, silly, they want more Airbnb.

The huffing then goes on in a similar vein that we’re used to with Airbnb’s market reports: it helps local people afford their homes and supports local communities. “When guests stay in hotels,” the report says “they spend money in hotels. For every dollar guests spend on Airbnb in the EU, they spend an average of $2.50 in the local community.”

In the luxury hotel sector, this number is closer to one dollar to eight. And that’s before you even address the idea that people in hotels spend all their money in hotels. If only. 

For everyone who has ever tried to develop a hotel, this report will raise anything from a wry smile to potentially life-alternating blood pressure. Hotels are subject to planning laws and strategies. They are part of a wider whole. Now, some of those planners might be crackers, but the theory is that there is at least a theory. Airbnb is only subject to the lightest of registration and licensing and, even then, not everywhere. 

And that’s before you look at what else a hotel brings. Jobs. Careers. Entry-level-to-CEO careers. As the saying goes, teach a man to fish etc etc. Airbnb might help you pay your rent, but it doesn’t get you a place on the board. It’s time to count those fingers. 

Scroll to Top