Asset class or brand? Hotels pick a side 

You might think that all of hospitality is, well, all of hospitality but, even if you stop trying really, really hard to think of student accommodation as hospitality, it’s still very hard to homogenise the remainder effectively. 

This was hammered home at a recent Propel Info event, where a data provider shared the latest UK performance for the different sectors in hospitality. Pubs and bars were there – both unbranded and branded – casual dining, coffee shops, coffee and sandwiches, fast food, it was all going on. Unless you were a hotel, in which case, good luck.

And this is probably a question for the incoming CEO of UKHospitality, but some days looking after the sector must feel like trying to stop the Conservative Party from cleaving itself along its lines of principle. Oh no, wait.

The differences in attitude and understanding were no more apparent than in the appearance of Sir Tim Martin, founder & chair, JD Wetherspoon and Simon Chaplin, senior director, pubs & restaurants, Christie & Co. 

For those who don’t pay attention to the pub sector – and apparently we have our silos – JD Wetherspoon has to expand more, preferably from 650 pubs to 1,000 and is thinking of marrying up with hotels. Now, it already has over 50 hotels of its own, so it’s not that. The group is instead thinking of offering franchises so you can pop a JD Wetherspoon into a bit of spare space you might have. And who hasn’t wondered what to do with that barely-used ballroom. 

Chaplin told the assembled: “We’re talking to a lot of operators who have one hotel or 10 or 15, where if they can get that bar or restaurant right they can compete.” They included, he said, Holiday Inns. 

We’re not going to get into specific deals in this column (apart from when we do, ooo Pandox and Dalata) and it’s entirely possible that a Holiday Inn franchisee would fancy popping a JD Wetherspoon into their disused ballroom. After all, the sector is slowly coming around to the idea of revenue per available square metre over revenue per available room. Whether IHG would fancy that is an issue we look forward to seeing played out.

But, as we have been forced to think recently, thanks largely to Hairbnb (tm, the Financial Times), while hospitality may look all the very same at a casual glance – it’s being nice to people for money, right?* – the brands within are positioned differently.

Take last year’s freakout about dynamic pricing when trying to buy Oasis tickets. What was bad for non-Blur fans is standard practice for people buying hotel rooms, where the customer is fully aware of the role of supply and demand, peak and trough times and has made its peace with them. With Oasis there’s a case to be made when you consider all those tickets were for the same date and time, so it was less strategy and more gouging, but you get the general mood.

The same is true across hospitality. At a recent restaurant conference, the CFO of a well-known brand told attendees that they were planning to pass on cost increases to customers by charging more for the same dishes in affluant neighbourhoods. This makes some practical sense – rents will be higher, after all – but caused a great deal of huffing and puffing from the Communists out there.

Why? When hotels do it all the time? That Holiday Inn isn’t going to be the same place across the UK or even across the same city. The difference is that a hotel brand is for the owners and the pub, restaurant and coffee/sandwich/casual dining chains are closer to consumer brands and all the moral weight that comes with that.

Are hotels cut out of hospitality data boards because they have no morals? No. But they might be left behind because they don’t hold such a fond place in the minds of their guests and their community. Should they put a JD Wetherspoon in the basement to make up for it? Probably not. Are they seen less as part of hospitality and more as a real estate investment class? It might not be the worst thing and we can keep our dynamic pricing. But if you’re planning on driving growth through, say, a loyalty programme, you might want to think again. 

*we jest, The Internet. It’s ‘the work or business of providing food and drink, entertainment, hotels, etc. for customers‘, says the Cambridge Dictionary. Very different. 

Scroll to Top