Back in the day, when former IHG CEO and (suspected) biohacking early adopter, Ageless Keith Barr, was still in his larval stage, he was CEO of IHG’s Greater China business. When he was promoted, observers were all very excited and not just because this was a great moment for pre-pubescent career development.
In his China time Barr had overseen the launch of the Hualuxe Hotels and Resorts brand which was described as “the first upscale, international hotel brand designed specifically for the Chinese traveller”. This meant a focus on tradition (“late night noodle bar”), rejuvenation (“resort inspired bathroom”), status (“a seamless VIP arrival”) and familiar spaces (“a tea room”).
The company now has 22 open hotels under the brand and 25 in the pipeline, so Barr must have been onto something.
IHG has a long tradition of doing things differently in China, with Barr’s successor, Kenneth Macpherson, announcing the launch of a franchise model for its Holiday Inn Express brand in China. The model, called Franchise Plus, was specifically tailored for the Chinese market and provided, the group said: “all of the benefits of operating a franchise model, but with additional benefits and features from IHG’s managed model”.
Then we had the pandemic and China became more of a millstone.
At this most-recent results season, China is back. Marriott president & CEO Tony Capuano told analysts that he wasn’t afraid of tariffs: “Almost the entirety of our portfolio and pipeline is Chinese owned. I don’t think there is a view in that market that we are just a big American company, we are seen as a Chinese company”. So there. And, and the time of writing, tariffs are a mere 30%, which is, like, barely the price of a flying air palace (if you get it free from Qatar).
Back at IHG, CEO Elie Maalouf said: “There is a lot of bearish narrative around China, and I am sure that is affecting a lot of industries. Things are steadying up in China. Could we be flattish in revpar this year there? I think we are in the game for that. But as I said last year, we could be flat. I think it can be flat again.
“The positive thing I will say about China is, there is a lot of people that have belief there with our openings being double, our strong signings in Q1, I think we are headed towards another record year of signings and openings in China. There is confidence locally with investors in our brands and in the hospitality market.”
And it is a local market. Maalouf pointed out that, in the US, its business was 95% domestic. In China, it was over 80% domestic. Barr’s branding of Chinese hotels for Chinese people had this in mind – and the hope that outbound travel would boom and these brands would spread with it.
What did boom for a while was outbound investment, until unusual accidents starting befalling the country’s CEOs. We all enjoyed the antics around HNA Group and Radisson. One of the more interesting deals was between Accor and the-then China Lodging, now H World. Mutual shareholdings were sold, but H World retains the rights as master franchisee for Mercure, Ibis and Ibis Styles, and co-development rights for Grand Mercure and Novotel, in the pan-China region.
The big outbound investment has been curtailed, for the moment. The domestic market is up for grabs. In 2024, H World achieved the 10,000-hotel milestone and for FY 2025 it expects to open around 2,300 hotels and close around 600 hotels. Marriott has close to 9,100 properties, with more than 500 in China.
Now H World focuses on the economy and midscale mass market, but it is playing in the high end. At the end of last year 9% of its open hotels were upscale, but 21% of its pipeline.
Earnings wise, the comparison falls apart a little. H World’s EBITDA in the fourth quarter of 2024 $134m and at Marriott it was $1.29bn. Should the non-China sector start to think harder about H World and its colleagues? After all, Airbnb has more than 8 million active listings and hotels have long stopped thinking about it.
What H World offers is scale and recognition for your brand, if not oodles of cash. The outbound tourism market is now firmly rebounding in China and, as we know, people like to stay where they recognise the sign over the door. Is it worth handing over your brand to an H World, so that a traveller calls ‘snap’ when they land in Paris? Or can the likes of Marriott really take on China?
Image: IHG’s Four Upper-Midscale Brands in Greater China (From clockwise: Atwell Suites, EVEN Hotels, Holiday Inn, Holiday Inn Express).