Last week we attended the STRZ short-term rental conference, where the solution to the housing crisis being laid at the feet of tourism was laid at the feet of old folk, with a drastic solution suggested. All in jest and we’re not there yet, but the STR sector continues to be the whipping boy of both hotels and government.
What is certain is that the sector must be regulated, but must not be wiped out. It provides a valuable service, one which the core hotel sector is slow to emulate: the ability for groups to travel together. But what it cannot do is pop up in residential areas hosting 24/7 hen nights, with neighbours being told: “well it could be a hotel here”. No, it could not.
That solved, results season continues Marriott, was continuing to address the Airbnb problem, most recently with its licensing deal with Sonder, which expanded its portfolio of longer-stay accommodations in key global markets, including New York and Dubai.
At Airbnb itself, the group’s share price fell 4% on the news it was having to spend money on marketing (regular viewers will recall the year of the IPO the group had gleefully announced it wasn’t paying for coverage. During an IPO year? Amazing. Still, transpires that you can’t have an IPO every year). Still, it worked and the company posted a third-quarter gross booking value of $20.1bn and revenue of $3.73bn, both up 10%, compared with a year earlier.
As in the hotel sector, pipeline is everything and the platform has been following two strands: getting rid of the rubbish sites (and helping to cut host cancellation rates by 30%) and encouraging new properties with its co-host platform.
For those who may have missed it, you might feel like renting out your penthouse in New York but just can’t be arsed with the faff. Why not have another host do it for you? As we noted at the time, this is not tremendous news for the companies who make a living managing short-term rentals. It may encourage them to up their game into experiences, through products such as that recently launched by Alliants and Hospiria.
The co-host network has shades of Tupperware parties to it, but the group said that: “in the three weeks since launch, we’ve received tremendous interest from over 20,000 potential new co-hosts”. So if you have a lovely lovely property, beware neighbours coming knocking looking to take a cut.
Another area where the two sectors collide is their enthusiasm for Doing Other Things. At Marriott, the company has signed a deal with Starbucks so that, as Tony Capuano put it, “even members with only one hotel stay can now redeem points for a cup of coffee”. This is it, people, this is the loyalty model, the augmented hospitality Accor is going for. Where the hotel company is able to touch you every day, not every stay. We watch with massive interest.
Airbnb, which is not, as yet, tied down by a loyalty programme is however preparing for its
“next chapter, which will take us beyond accommodations. You’ll see more on this next year,” it said, with an OOOooooooOOo and a wave of its hands.
We know that Experiences is due back and it will be intriguing to see whether the company is able to manage this at scale, without buying a specialist company or two (it’s likely it will buy a specialist company or two). The failure of Experiences first time out laid bare the difference between Airbnb and its rivals in the hotel sector: the people.
Yes, we have all enjoyed that motivated host who told us where the good happy hour was and left out a bottle of wine and even this taught the hotel sector much that had been lost in terms of service. But now the hotel sector has caught up and, with teams in place on site, can deliver more.
With Airbnb’s estate largely standalone units, rather than the old flat-sharing model, experiences are harder to achieve. One host who knows a sommelier to do wine tasting or a chef to teach a local dish does not a summer make.
Hotels have gained the upper hand after a difficult learning process, but they’re pretty canny at Airbnb. Next year is likely to come with a steep learning curve.