Will Whitbread go from budget flag to white flag?

Eighties classic RoboCop features a board meeting in which a proposed law enforcement droid accidentally kills off a junior employee, resulting in one less mouth to feed and a change of strategy at Omni Consumer Products. 

Much as one should separate films from reality when considering your five-year plan, one can imagine how Whitbread’s executives might have sighed wistfully at such unorthodox solutions when considering the latest move from 7% shareholder Corvex Management, which has gone from calling for a strategic review in December to calling for a sale of the whole company in May.

What has happened in the intervening months to cause such drama at a group we used to know as ‘boring, boring Whitbread’? Well the share price is down almost 15% on the year, but so would you be if you were trying to run a hotel in the UK at the moment. A 15% drop seems almost unseemly in its hopefulness.

Away from the macro environment, Whitbread upset Corvex very much by announcing a five-year plan the activist didn’t like following the strategic review. Whitbread CEO Dominic Paul concluded “our model is the right one”. One can see how, if you’d spent the intervening months saying things like “the status quo is untenable”, then that might not be the message you were hoping for if you were Corvex.

Actually, Paul not only announced that they were right all along, he announced plans to create “a higher-margin, higher-returning pure-play hotel business”, getting rid of Brewers Fayre and Beefeater and selling £1.5bn of freehold property and leasing it back. A staggering level of activity for the normally-staid Whitbread.

But, having taken their dinner money, Corvex is now eyeing the full pension pot and struck back with a petulant letter from managing partner Keith Meister, or, to give him his full title when mentioned by any member of the press; ‘Carl Icahn’s protégé Keith Meister’. This is meant to be frightening, because, for those unaware, Carl Icahn was the inspiration for Gordon Gekko, the main character in Wall Street. Wall Street came out the same year as RoboCop and took a much less fluffy approach to board meetings.

Forty years on, Meister appears to be confirming to type, taking a somewhat firm approach in his writing and if you have a latte and a spare five minutes, it’s certainly worth your time, here. In a fine example of the genre, Meister complains that he had really just wanted to get along with the board – “we sought to be collaborative” but that Whitbread told it to “wait and see” and look what happened, just look. 

For Meister, the £1.5bn sale is good money after bad  – “monetising the company’s most valuable freehold assets to fund these highly uncertain growth investments” – and what’s worse, the market STILL isn’t valuing the company correctly. In fact, Meister said, the share priced implied that the market “is ascribing zero value to Whitbread’s remaining leasehold business, its German hotel assets, and its development properties currently under construction and not yet trading”.

We’d grasp at our pearls, but, much as we enjoy a lease, saying that the market doesn’t know how to value them isn’t really news, Keith. 

Meister was, of course, forced to conclude that “the only credible path to unlocking that value is a sale of the company”. I know. You’re shocked, we’re shocked, who could possibly have seen this coming? And while they’re at it, the company’s free cash flow should be returned to shareholders through an accelerated share repurchase programme. 

Whitbread responded that it was sticking to the plan and Corvex has threatened to start proposing board members. Cue a few months of ‘actually, Attila the Hun will be a great hotel non exec because of his ability to feed and house an army on the move’. 

What would this new owner, who, at the time of writing, would need £4.06bn to spend on a UK-heavy budget hotel brand, do with Whitbread? Meister has not as yet been drawn on such matters, although it’s not growth, having written that “neither market conditions nor the company’s underlying performance justifying such expansion” – the such expansion being 14,000 rooms across the UK and Germany over the next five years.

No one has come sniffing around Whitbread for a good long while and Pandox can’t buy everything that the markets don’t like. One must assume that Meister has a chum somewhere who wishes to buy the group and sell off its freehold assets, reported to be worth anything up to 50% more than its current market cap. Which is a lot of property to dump onto the market at once. 

Whitbread is an outlier in the sector, being very asset heavy indeed, while also having very high brand recognition. On the surface, going asset light and focusing on the brand feels sane in this environment. But being asset backed is what has got Whitbread where it is today in terms of stability and growth.

Corvex appears to think that Whitbread has gone as far as it can go. Whitbread believes that there are still independents to convert in the UK and a whole bunch of space in Germany. Without real estate to fund it, a post-sale Whitbread would have to compete on brand alone for sites. With no loyalty programme it relies on its strong brand recognition to drive direct booking – something it has so far been unable to replicate in Germany. 

Would a post-sale Whitbread make an attractive target for, say, a Marriott looking to continue the move downmarket? Possibly, although taking budget into Europe would mean taking on Accor on home ground. All roads lead to a Marriott, Accor merger, as always they must. 

To hold off Corvex, Whitbread either needs to dig deeper into the 80s classics or find a white knight with a big stick and an enthusiasm for slow, steady growth over generations. With attention spans falling by the moment, it might be a hard sell. 

Scroll to Top